支持前者
Authorities such as the central government can make more far-‐reaching decisions because they are clearer of the overall situation of a country than individual teachers.
The government is more capable of pooling maximum social resources and education experts to set up curriculum and to compose unified textbooks.
The opinions from individual teachers vary from person to person, which cannot guarantee the overall teaching outcomes. Even some teachers may convey overly subjective views to students.
支持后者
The more efficient we expect teaching to be, the more individualised it has to become, and only teachers who has rich practical experience know how to tell the real needs of every student, what advantages they have and what they are lack of
It is hardly feasible for the central government to take care of detail teaching contents, especially for big countries, and uniformed contents may end up being inappropriate, e.g. the different states in the USA lay more stress on their own historic account in textbooks; the regional gap in education level can be a headache for authorities.
Academics need the soil of freedom to thrive. If the central government conducted overly strict regulations, real academics would not survive.
论据共享题 同套路题
政府制定健康的生活方式
Some people think the government should act to decide how people live in order to make a healthier life. Others think individuals should decide their own lifestyle. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
